Comice Pear
Often called the Christmas pear, considered by many to be the finest-flavored pear variety with incredibly sweet, buttery, melt-in-your-mouth flesh.
On this pageOverview
Meet Comice Pear
Often called the Christmas pear, considered by many to be the finest-flavored pear variety with incredibly sweet, buttery, melt-in-your-mouth flesh. Comice pears are traditionally paired with cheese and are the variety used in luxury fruit gift boxes. The trees are less vigorous and productive than other varieties but the superior fruit quality is worth the wait.
When to plant Comice Pear
Comice pears are exclusively propagated by grafting, as seedlings will not reproduce the prized fruit characteristics. For rootstock production, cold-stratify pear seeds at 33 to 40 degrees Fahrenheit for 60 to 90 days in moist sand or peat. Sow stratified seeds half an inch deep in spring in deep containers. Graft Comice scion wood onto compatible rootstock such as OHxF 87 or OHxF 333 during the following dormant season. Note that Comice requires an interstem when grafted onto quince rootstock.
Your Comice Pear Year
Composed for Zone 7 · typical seasons · frost passes Apr 2, returns Nov 1
Sow Comice Pear Mar – Apr, pick Sep – Oct. Set your climate below and every date on this plate re-times itself.
How to grow Comice Pear
Comice pears demand a sheltered site with full sun and protection from strong winds, as the heavy fruit bruises easily when knocked from branches. Plant in deep, fertile, well-drained loam with a pH of 6.0 to 7.0. Space standard trees 18 to 20 feet apart and semi-dwarf trees 12 to 15 feet apart. Set the graft union above the soil line and stake young trees for the first two to three years as they establish.
Comice pears require cross-pollination and Bartlett is the most reliable partner. The trees bloom midseason and have a shorter bloom window than other varieties, so ensure pollinators are active. Prune to a modified central leader form with well-spaced scaffold branches. Comice grows less vigorously than Bartlett or Anjou, so pruning can be lighter.
Thin fruit to one or two per cluster when fruitlets are thumbnail-sized to promote large, high-quality fruit. Water consistently through the growing season, providing one to two inches per week, and increase slightly during the fruit sizing period. Apply a moderate amount of balanced fertilizer in early spring, keeping nitrogen conservative to minimize fire blight risk and maintain the compact growth habit.
Comice Pear needs more room than a 4 × 8 ft bed gives
Each Comice Pear wants 300 cm of elbow room. The planner keeps that spacing for you — every plant, every bed.
Comice Pear's best neighbours
Plant garlic, chives, and marigolds around Comice pear trees to deter borers and aphids. Comfrey grown as a dynamic accumulator provides excellent mulch material rich in potassium. Low-growing herbs like thyme and oregano can serve as aromatic ground covers that attract pollinators. Clover or alfalfa between rows fixes nitrogen naturally. Avoid planting near walnut trees due to juglone toxicity and near juniper species that can harbor pear rust.
Garlic belongs beside it. Walnut Tree doesn't.
Old growers' knowledge, checked against Comice Pear's real companion table below — test any plant you're growing.
Feed it well
Comice pears require rich, deep, well-drained soil with a pH of 6.0 to 7.0 and consistent moisture availability. They are less tolerant of poor soils than Bartlett or Anjou and respond well to annual compost applications. Fertilize conservatively in early spring with a balanced formula, as Comice trees are naturally less vigorous and excess nitrogen promotes fire blight susceptibility. Apply potassium-rich supplements if fruit quality is declining. Maintain a deep organic mulch layer to conserve moisture and regulate soil temperature.
Ideal Temperature
Hardiness Zone Compatibility
From seed to harvest, stage by stage
Dormancy
The tree rests through winter months, conserving energy for the coming season. Buds remain tightly closed and the tree shows no active growth. This period is essential for meeting chilling hour requirements that trigger proper spring flowering.
Bud Swell and Bloom
As temperatures warm, buds swell and burst open to reveal clusters of delicate white five-petaled blossoms. Comice pear flowers are produced on spurs and must be cross-pollinated by a compatible variety such as Bosc or Anjou within a few days of opening.
Fruit Set and Early Development
Fertilized flowers drop their petals and small fruitlets begin to swell at the base. The tree may naturally shed some fruitlets in the June drop, a self-thinning process. Remaining fruits develop rapidly, drawing carbohydrates and nutrients from leaves.
Fruit Bulking
Comice pears undergo their most rapid size increase during summer. The distinctive rounded, short-necked shape becomes apparent. Skin transitions from bright green toward a more muted yellow-green. Sugar accumulation and cell expansion occur simultaneously during this stage.
Maturation and Harvest
Fruit approaches physiological maturity in late September to October. Comice pears must be harvested before they are fully ripe on the tree, as they ripen from the inside out and will become mealy if left too long. The stem separates cleanly when the fruit is lifted and rotated.
Post-Harvest and Leaf Drop
After harvest the tree redirects energy into root development and carbohydrate storage in the wood. Leaves yellow and drop as the tree enters senescence. This phase is critical for building reserves that will fuel the following year's bloom and early growth.
Apply dormant oil spray during a mild day to smother overwintering pests and fungal spores. Complete any structural pruning now before bud swell begins.
Caring for Comice Pear month by month
What to do each month for your Comice Pear
July
You are hereContinue regular irrigation. Inspect for codling moth damage and place pheromone traps to time spray applications. Apply a summer oil if woolly aphid colonies are detected.
Harvesting Comice Pear
Comice pears should be harvested when mature but still firm, typically in mid to late October. Test readiness by applying gentle pressure at the stem end; the fruit should separate from the spur with a slight upward tilt. The skin may develop a yellow blush or slight softening near the stem when ready. After harvest, Comice pears need two to four weeks of cold storage at 30 to 32 degrees Fahrenheit before ripening at room temperature for five to seven days. Handle with extreme care as the delicate skin bruises easily.
assuming you sow when the window opens — set your real date
Pick Comice Pear promptly and the plant keeps producing.
Storage & Preservation
Comice pears store for two to three months at 30 to 32 degrees Fahrenheit with 90 percent humidity. They are primarily a fresh eating pear due to their extraordinary butter-smooth texture. For preservation, make pear butter or can in light syrup. Comice pears are too soft when ripe for drying but can be frozen in syrup pack for later use in smoothies and desserts. Their exquisite flavor is best appreciated fresh, paired with fine cheese and wine.
What goes wrong — and the fix
Fire Blight
DiseaseBlossom clusters turn brown and die; shoot tips blacken and curl; bark cankers ooze amber-colored bacterial slime.
Pear Psylla
PestHoneydew deposits cause sooty mold on leaves and fruit; leaf curling and yellowing; reduced fruit size and quality.
Botrytis Blossom Blight
DiseaseFlowers turn brown and develop a fuzzy gray mold; infected blossoms fail to set fruit; disease spreads in cool, wet conditions.
Troubleshooting Common Problems
Comice pears are notoriously difficult to grow compared to other pear varieties. The trees are less productive, slower to begin bearing, and more susceptible to fire blight than hardier cultivars. Fruit set can be erratic due to the narrow bloom window and sensitivity to poor weather during pollination. The delicate skin bruises extremely easily during harvest and handling, requiring very gentle treatment. Comice on certain rootstocks can develop graft incompatibility, so choose proven combinations like OHxF series.
Growing Tips
- Comice pear is self-sterile and will not set fruit without a compatible pollinator variety within 15 meters. Plant at least one Bosc, Anjou, or Conference pear nearby and ensure both bloom at overlapping times.
- Select a planting site with excellent air drainage to reduce frost risk during bloom. Frost pockets formed by low-lying terrain or walls that trap cold air can eliminate the entire crop in a single late spring frost event.
- Comice is particularly susceptible to fire blight, a bacterial disease that can kill shoots and even entire limbs rapidly during warm wet spring conditions. Use copper-based preventive sprays at bloom and prune out any blighted shoots immediately, sterilizing cuts with a 10% bleach solution.
- Harvest Comice pears before they are ripe on the tree. The correct harvest moment is when the fruit separates cleanly from the spur with a gentle upward twist and the flesh near the stem gives very slightly to firm thumb pressure. Leaving fruit on the tree until it looks ripe results in mealy, unpleasant flesh.
- After picking, Comice pears require a cold storage period of at least two to four weeks at 0 to 1°C before they ripen well at room temperature. Pears picked and immediately ripened at room temperature without cold conditioning often fail to develop their full buttery texture and flavor.
- Espalier training against a south-facing wall in cooler climates concentrates heat and light onto the fruit, dramatically improving flavor development and sugar accumulation in regions that would otherwise be marginal for this variety.
- Thinning is not optional with Comice — it is essential. Without aggressive thinning to a single fruit per spur, the tree will produce small, poorly flavored fruit and often biennial bear, producing a large crop one year and almost nothing the next.
- Pear psylla is one of the most damaging pests of Comice and can cause significant sooty mold buildup and fruit russeting. Monitor for honeydew deposits on leaves in spring and apply horticultural oil or insecticidal soap before populations build.
- Comice grown on quince rootstock is more precocious and compact than on pear seedling rootstock, beginning to fruit at 3 to 4 years versus 6 to 8, but is more sensitive to wet soils and lime-induced chlorosis. Amend heavy clay soils before planting and ensure drainage is excellent.
- Mulching with a 10 cm layer of wood chips or straw around the base of the tree, kept well away from the trunk, conserves soil moisture, moderates soil temperature, and reduces competition from grass and weeds, all of which directly improve fruit size and quality.
Pick your Comice Pear
Doyenne du Comice
The original French variety with exceptional buttery texture and complex sweet flavor; the standard by which dessert pears are judged.
Red Comice
A red-blushed sport with the same superb eating quality and slightly more attractive appearance for gift giving.
Comice on Quince C
A dwarfing rootstock combination producing a compact 8 to 10 foot tree ideal for small gardens; needs an interstem.
Comice on OHxF 333
A semi-dwarf combination offering good fire blight resistance in the rootstock with improved precocity.
A mature Comice pear tree in a home garden can produce 40 to 100 kg of fruit per year, potentially saving a household several hundred dollars annually compared to purchasing premium Comice pears at retail prices, where they typically sell for $4 to $8 per kilogram or more. Gift-quality Comice pears sold through specialty mail-order companies often cost $50 to $80 per box, meaning even a modest harvest represents considerable value for the home grower.
Quick recipes
Comice Pear and Gorgonzola Crostini
15 minutesAn elegant appetizer that celebrates the classic pairing of sweet Comice pear with creamy, pungent Gorgonzola on toasted sourdough. Finished with a drizzle of honey and toasted walnuts, this simple preparation lets the pear's buttery flavor take center stage.
7 ingredientsPoached Comice Pears in Red Wine
45 minutesWhole Comice pears gently poached in spiced red wine until tender and deeply colored, then served with a reduced syrup. This classic French preparation highlights the variety's ability to hold its shape while absorbing complex aromatic flavors.
8 ingredientsComice Pear and Almond Tart
30 minutes preparation, 40 minutes bakingA classic French-inspired frangipane tart filled with rich almond cream and topped with sliced Comice pears. The buttery sweetness of the pear melds perfectly with the nutty, fragrant filling for a show-stopping dessert that is simpler to make than it appears.
9 ingredientsCulinary Uses
Comice pears are considered the ultimate dessert pear, best enjoyed fresh at the peak of ripeness when the flesh is impossibly smooth and buttery. They are the classic pairing with blue cheese, Brie, or aged Gouda on cheese boards. Serve sliced with prosciutto and drizzled with honey for an elegant appetizer. Comice pears make luxurious pear tarts and are excellent in fresh fruit salads where their melt-in-your-mouth texture can be fully appreciated.
What's inside
Health Benefits
- The high soluble fiber content in Comice pears, primarily pectin, helps lower LDL cholesterol by binding bile acids in the digestive tract and promoting their excretion.
- Comice pears provide a significant dose of antioxidant flavonoids and hydroxycinnamic acids that help neutralize free radicals and reduce oxidative stress associated with chronic disease.
- The natural prebiotic fiber and sorbitol content support a healthy and diverse gut microbiome, contributing to improved immune function and reduced inflammation.
- With a moderate glycemic index and high water content, Comice pears promote satiety without causing sharp blood sugar spikes, making them a smart snack choice for blood glucose management.
- The vitamin C and copper in Comice pears both support collagen synthesis, contributing to healthy skin, cartilage, and wound healing.
- Regular consumption of pears has been associated in epidemiological studies with reduced risk of type 2 diabetes, likely due to the combined effects of dietary fiber, antioxidants, and anti-inflammatory phytonutrients.
Where Comice Pear comes from
The Comice pear, known formally as Doyenné du Comice, is a French variety with roots in the mid-nineteenth century horticultural culture of the Loire Valley. It was raised from a seedling at the Comice Horticole de Maine-et-Loire in Angers, France, and first described and distributed around 1849. The Comice Horticole was an agricultural society dedicated to improving regional horticulture, and the pear that bore its name quickly became one of the most celebrated fruits to emerge from that era of systematic pomological exploration. Within decades of its introduction, it had been adopted by growers across Western Europe and was considered a benchmark variety for dessert quality.
The variety made its way to the Pacific Northwest of the United States in the late nineteenth century, where it found an exceptional match in the volcanic soils and continental climate of the Rogue River Valley in southern Oregon. The region's warm sunny days and cool nights during the fruit development period proved ideal for concentrating the sugars and aromatic compounds that define the Comice character. By the early twentieth century, Oregon growers were producing Comice pears of extraordinary quality, and in the 1930s the orchard business Harry and David began shipping gift boxes of these pears nationally under the trademarked name Royal Riviera Pears, transforming the Comice from a regional specialty into a luxury food item recognized across North America.
In France, the variety remained a staple of fine fruit culture, often appearing in high-end patisserie and cheese shops throughout the twentieth century, where it was paired with Roquefort, Brie, and other artisan cheeses. The British also adopted the Comice enthusiastically, and it remains one of the most popular garden pear varieties in the United Kingdom to this day.
Modern interest in heirloom and heritage fruit varieties has renewed appreciation for the Comice. Despite being over 170 years old, no hybrid or modern breeding program has produced a dessert pear that consistently surpasses it in flavor and texture. It remains the standard against which other pear varieties are measured by pomologists and food professionals alike.
Comice Pear: did you know?
Fascinating facts about Comice Pear
Comice pear originated in Angers, France, around 1849 at the Comice Horticole, a horticultural society whose name the variety still carries today.
Comice Pear questions, answered
When should I plant Comice Pear?
What are good companion plants for Comice Pear?
What hardiness zones can Comice Pear grow in?
How much sun does Comice Pear need?
How far apart should I space Comice Pear?
What pests and diseases affect Comice Pear?
How do I store Comice Pear after harvest?
What are the best Comice Pear varieties to grow?
What soil does Comice Pear need?
Why are my Comice pears mealy and bland even though they look ripe?
My Comice pear tree blooms every year but never sets any fruit. What is wrong?
What is the best way to tell when Comice pears are ready to harvest?
How long does it take for a Comice pear tree to produce fruit?
Can I grow Comice pear in a small garden or in a container?
Why does my Comice tree produce a large crop one year and almost no fruit the next?
You just read the theory. Now grow it on autopilot.
Everything that makes Comice Pear fiddly — the timing, the spacing, the companions, the harvest window — is exactly what PlotMyGarden handles for you, for every plant in your garden.
A plan that knows your weather
Set your location once. Get sow, feed and harvest dates built around your real last-frost date and live forecast — no more guessing from a generic seed packet.
From the “When to plant” sectionDrag-and-drop bed planner
Design beds on a grid. Every plant snaps to its proper spacing, and you can see your whole season laid out before you spend a cent on seed.
From the “Growing guide” sectionCompanion conflicts, caught early
200+ good-and-bad pairings checked live as you plant — so a season-wrecking mistake never makes it into the ground.
From the “Companions” sectionReminders you'll actually act on
“Water the beans.” “Pick today before it turns.” Timely, specific, and tied to the plants you're really growing.
From the “Harvest” sectionSuccession, scheduled
Want a harvest for six weeks, not six days? It spaces your sowings automatically and reminds you when each new block is due.
From the “When to plant” sectionA record that gets smarter
Every harvest you log teaches it your garden. Next year's plan starts from what actually worked in your soil, not a textbook's.
From the “Overview” sectionPlant these alongside Comice Pear
More Pome Fruits
Keep Comice Pear away from these
Grow your best Comice Pear yet — and everything around it.
Start a free plan today. Lay out your beds, drop in your Comice Pear, and let PlotMyGarden handle the timing, spacing, companions and reminders from seed to harvest basket.